WASHINGTON, DC (CWNews.com) - The US Supreme Court today
rejected an appeal of state laws that grant Good Friday as
a legal holiday and prepared to receive arguments on
Wednesday in whether so-called "bubble zones" around
abortion clinics are constitutional.
In the first case, the high court, without comment,
rejected a retired Maryland teacher's appeal in which she
claimed that the state's closing of public schools on Good
Friday and Easter Monday violated the separation of church
and state. Thirteen states designate Good Friday as a legal
holiday but only three -- Maryland, Illinois, and North
Dakota -- require all public schools to close on Good
Friday. A federal appeals court has struck down the
Illinois law, and the Supreme Court has not said whether it
will review the ruling.
The Maryland law was upheld by the 4th US Circuit Court of
Appeals after it was challenged by Judith Koenick, a former
teacher who is Jewish. She said the law "sends the message
to non-Christians that the state finds Good Friday, and
thus Christianity, to be a religion worth honoring while
their religion or nonreligion is not of equal importance."
On Wednesday, the justices will hear arguments on whether a
1993 Colorado law requiring pro-life demonstrators to
maintain a specific distance from people entering abortion
clinics violates free speech or is a legal protection
against harassment.
James Henderson of the Virginia-based American Center for
Law and Justice, which represents the protesters, contends
that the law tramples on free-speech rights. "My way of
sidewalk counseling is to be gentle and to be
compassionate. Colorado's way is to put me so far away I
have to scream and yell," said Jeanne Hill, one of three
pro-lifers challenging the law. Fourteen states and several
cities have passed laws creating "bubble zones" around
people entering clinics and "buffer zones" around the
clinics themselves.
The Supreme Court returned the Colorado case to state
courts in 1997 to reconsider it in wake of the high court's
decision in a New York case, in which the high court allowed
pro-lifers to interact with women on public sidewalks as
long as they stayed at least 15 feet from the clinic's
entrance. A Colorado appeals court again upheld the law,
noting it was enacted by lawmakers, while the New York case
involved a judge's injunction.