OTTAWA (CWNews.com) - Canada's Justice Minister on Friday
introduced new legislation that would give the same
benefits to same-sex couples as enjoyed by common-law
couples, but without giving them the legal status of
marriage.
Justice Minister Anne McLellan's bill proposes changes to
about 60 laws, essentially declaring homosexual and lesbian
partnerships to have the same legal status as common-law
couples, including pension benefits and income tax
regulations, among others. McLellan said it represented
"the modernization of both benefits and obligations." She
said the Supreme Court made it "very clear ... that we have
to ensure equal treatment between common-law same-sex and
opposite-sex relations."
McLellan said the definition of marriage is "very clear" in
Canadian law. "Marriage is a relationship between one man
and one woman to the exclusion of all others. There is
absolutely no confusion about that."
Reform Party legislator Eric Lowther said there were
weaknesses in the legislation. Under the bill, qualifying
for benefits is "contingent upon private physical intimacy.
There must be a conjugal type of relationship," he said.
"That excludes a lot of people that might otherwise qualify
(but) don't have a sexual relationship," he said. How would
officials know whether "roommates are just roommates or
people (in) a conjugal relationship?" The government should
not be asking people "what's your private sex life," in
order for them to qualify for benefits, Lowther said.