First question. Again the monk appeared on his ladder as before saying: "O
Judge, why did you create worms that are harmful and useless?"
Second question. "Why did you create wild beasts that are also harmful to
humankind?"
Third question. "Why do you let sickness and pain into bodies?"
Fourth question. "Why do you endure the wickedness of wicked judges who
scourge and harass their underlings like purchased slaves?"
Fifth question. "Why is the human body afflicted even at the point of death?"
Answer to the first question. The Judge answered: "Friend, as God and Judge I
have created heaven and earth and all that are in them, and yet nothing without
cause nor without some likeness to spiritual things. Just as the souls of holy people
resemble the holy angels who live and are happy, so too the souls of the
unrighteous become like the demons who are eternally dying. Therefore, since you
asked why I created worms, I answer you that I created them in order to show forth
the manifold power of my wisdom and goodness. For, although they can be
harmful, nevertheless they do no harm without my permission and only when sin
demands it, so that man, who scorns to submit to his superior, may bemoan his
capacity to be afflicted by lesser creatures, and also in order that he may know
himself to be nothing without me - whom even the irrational creatures serve and
they all stand at my beck and call."
Answer to the second question. "As to why I created wild beasts, I answer: All
things that I have created are not only good but very good and have been created
either for the use or trial of humankind or for the use of other creatures and in order
that humans might so much the more humbly serve their God inasmuch as they are
more blessed than all the rest. However, beasts do harm in the temporal world for a
twofold reason. First, so that the wicked may be corrected and beware, and so that
wicked people might come to understand through their torments that they must
obey me, their superior. Second, they also do harm to good people with a view to
their advancement in virtue and for their purification. And because the human race
rebelled against me, their God, through sin, all those creatures that had been subject
to humans have consequently rebelled against them."
Answer to the third question. "As to why sickness comes upon the body, I
answer that this happens both as a strong warning and because of the vice of
incontinence and excess, in order that people may learn spiritual moderation and
patience by restraining the flesh."
Answer to the fourth question. "As to why wicked judges are tolerated, this is
for the purification of others and also because of my patience, in order that, just as
gold is purified by fire, so too, by the evil of scoundrels, souls may be purified and
instructed and held back from doing what they should not do. Furthermore, I
patiently tolerate the wicked so as to separate the devil's chaff from the wheat of the
good, and in order to fulfill their wishes according to my hidden, divine justice."
Answer to the fifth question. "As to why the body suffers pain in death, it is
just that a person should be punished by means of that in which she or he has
sinned. If she sins through inordinate lust, it is right for her to be punished with
proportionate bitterness and pain. For that reason, death begins for some people on
earth and will last without end in hell, while death ends for others in purgatory and
everlasting joy commences."