DARWIN, AUSTRALIA, APR 12 (ZENIT.org).- An aborted baby survived 80
minutes while the hospital staff waited for her to die, according to
testimony at a coroner's court in Darwin, Australia, yesterday. The
abortionist had induced labor in the mother to remove the 21-22-week-old
aborted fetus. However, the nurse-midwife found herself delivering a
live child.
Greg Cavanaugh, the coroner, said that there was a "responsibility
vacuum" when "Baby J" was unexpectedly born alive, leaving the nurse
with a moral dilemma. The nurse, Carrie Williams, said that she called
the Royal Darwin Hospital Obstetrics and Gynecology Department Director
Dr. Kai Man Henry Cho to report the live birth. The doctor reportedly
responded, "So?"
The Coroner said that no instructions were left for the nurses for such
an event. In the end, Williams did everything she could: she wrapped the
baby in a blanket and waited for her to die. Babies born before 22 weeks
seldom survive, and almost always require artificial assistance to
breathe properly. Even without this minimal care, "Baby J" lived more
than an hour.
The coroner ruled the cause of death to be premature delivery. He said
deaths after such live births, even if the gestational age made survival
impossible, should be reported to the coroner and the public had the
right to be informed and take part in any debate. The deceased should
not be described as 'fetus', an 'aborted fetus', a 'non-viable fetus' or
anything that diminished her status as a human being. Neither should
the purpose of the induction procedure be allowed to diminish her status
as a human being.
"The deceased having been born alive deserved all the dignity, respect
and value that our society places on human life," Mr Cavanagh said. "The
fact that her birth was unexpected and not the desired
outcome of the [abortion] should not result in her and babies like her
being perceived as anything less than a complete human being."
Australian Right to Life Chairwoman Margaret Tigue said that she hoped
the story of this baby's short life would "serve to remind others that
unborn babies are people too and are as deserving of their rights to
life as are all others."
ZE00041220