NEWS for Friday-Saturday-Sunday, June 30 - July 2, 2000
CODIFICATION OF GENOME COULD LEAD TO BIOGENETIC DICTATORSHIP
Comments of Bishop Elio Sgreccia of Pontifical Academy for Life
ROME, JUNE 28 (ZENIT.org)
A European organization must be
created, which will assign "labels" guaranteeing respect for
ethical norms and fundamental rights in research projects and
biological products. This was the answer given in the European
Parliament in Strasbourg, the day after the news of the progress
in the codification of the human genome.
The first draft of the human genome was presented last Monday.
Incurable illnesses like cancer and schizophrenia could be
prevented with therapeutic applications contained in deciphering
a human being's genetic map. The presentation, which took place
simultaneously in several countries of the world, included the
presence of Bill Clinton and Tony Blair. The British researchers
of the International Human Genome Project disclosed that it has
been possible to translate 97% of man's genetic map, knowledge
that is 85% precise.
However, some scientists give a different reading to these
discoveries, warning that there is still a long way to go before
arriving at a profound understanding of the structure and
function of genes, as well reaping benefits from this knowledge
for human health. We need to know how the genes function and
interact among themselves.
In simple language, the Human Genome Project has provided us with
the alphabet. We must now decipher the language -- a gigantic
puzzle made up of over 50 million pieces. Although there is
enthusiasm in the air because of the successes so far, there are
reservations and, in some sectors, fears over possible abuses.
In order to understand the situation better, Vatican Radio
interviewed Bishop Elio Sgreccia, vice-president of the
Pontifical Academy for Life, and director of the Bioethics
Institute of the University of the Sacred Heart in Rome.
According to Bishop Sgreccia, the news of the great progress made
in the codification of the human genetic map is a step comparable
"to the discovery of a continent or space flight. Now we must
hope that the the first objective in the use of these discoveries
is to prevent the causes that determine hereditary diseases and,
later, guarantee better knowledge of the mechanisms that
determine the formation of tumors. Of course there is the risk,
which calls for an imperative appeal to responsibility, that the
conquests made will be used to promote eugenics, that is, to
determine the selection between healthy and sick individuals, or
to give a kind of value to human existence in virtue of genetic
characteristics."
This would be an extremely dangerous dictatorship that, in
addition, would have all the information of our genetic
constitution. "Knowledge is power and, therefore, to know our
characteristics in a certain sense means to possess each one of
us. In addition to UNESCO's (United Nations Organization for
Education, Science, and Culture) Universal Declaration on the
Human Genome, we hope that laws will be promulgated that
establish the limits for the use of a discovery of this kind,"
Bishop Sgreccia cautioned.
Following the news of progress in the codification of the genome,
someone said there is nothing left to say about man and his
presence in the world. "Quite the contrary. Biological science
describes, it does not explain the ultimate cause of the origin
of life, the origin of reality and, above all, of this marvelous
structure, which can only be the fruit of intelligent causality.
Just as we say in the Psalm: 'The Heavens tell the glory of God,
and the firmament shows forth the work of his hands,' in this
case also, and with greater reason, we can see the greatness of
God in the order and beauty of the structure we decipher in our
cells. It is an attempt to explain what the person is, and
whether matter can explain intelligence and spirit or if, on the
contrary, it is the human spirit that rules the individual's
life. Anthropology, philosophy of science, and metaphysics are
more stimulated than ever by this discovery," Bishop Sgreccia
concluded.
ZE00062810
We encourage you to check the Catholic World News site at the
CWN home page and Church News at Noticias Eclesiales and the Dossiers, features and Daily Dispatches from ZENIT International News Agency CWN, NE and ZENIT are not affiliated with the Daily CATHOLIC, but provide this service via e-mail to the Daily CATHOLIC Monday through Friday.
|