NEWS for Friday-Saturday-Sunday, June 30 - July 2, 2000
REACTION TO SUPREME COURT DECISION ON PARTIAL-BIRTH ABORTION
WASHINGTON, DC (CWNews.com)
In the aftermath of the US
Supreme Court's decision to strike down a Nebraska law
banning partial-birth abortion on Wednesday, Congress
prepared new federal legislation banning the procedure, the
high court ordered lower courts to review similar laws in
other states, and many pro-life and pro-abortion groups
weighed in with their opinions.
House Judiciary Committee Chairman Henry Hyde, R-Illinois,
said lawmakers will study the court opinion as they
formulate a new proposal, including the court's requirement
of an exemption to protect the health of the mother.
President Bill Clinton vetoed two similar bills in 1996 and
1997. The new bill is expected to be on the president's desk
before the November elections.
The Supreme Court on Thursday also ordered lower courts to
restudy bans on partial-birth abortions in Illinois and
Wisconsin, taking into account the standards set by
Wednesday's ruling. The court also let stand a ruling that
struck down Iowa's ban on the procedure.
Pro-life groups were particularly disappointed at the
Supreme Court's decision on Wednesday, but held out hope
for the future. Bob Blank, president of Metro Right to
Life, a pro-life group in Omaha, Nebraska, called the
ruling a disappointment. "The Supreme Court of the United
States chose not to listen to the people of the United
States," he said.
Family Research Council vice president Chuck Donovan said
the ruling is not unexpected given the direction the court
has moved over the past three decades. "This is the lethal
logic of Roe v Wade (1973). There is no longer any doubt,"
he said. "Roe was succeeded by the ridiculous Casey ruling
(1992). In Casey, the court admitted it did not know if Roe
was right or wrong, but since the court is a very important
court, and since many people rely on abortion, the judges
said, in effect, everyone should shut up and go back to
work."
He added: "The Supreme Court's odious partial-birth
abortion ruling is the cruelest, most unjust ruling in
American history."
Republican presidential candidate George W. Bush said:
"States should have the right to enact reasonable laws and
restrictions, particularly to end the inhumane practice of
ending a life that would otherwise live," he said.
"I hope and expect that we can come up with a law that
meets constitutional muster, and unlike [Democratic
presidential candidate] Al Gore, I pledge to fight for a
ban on partial birth abortion," he said.
We encourage you to check the Catholic World News site at the
CWN home page and Church News at Noticias Eclesiales and the Dossiers, features and Daily Dispatches from ZENIT International News Agency CWN, NE and ZENIT are not affiliated with the Daily CATHOLIC, but provide this service via e-mail to the Daily CATHOLIC Monday through Friday.
|