First question. Again the monk appeared on his rung as before saying: "O
Judge, I ask you: Since you are God and man, why did you not reveal your divine
as well as your human nature, and then everyone would have believed in you?"
Second question. "Why did you not let all your words be heard in an instant,
and then it would not have been necessary for them to be preached over intervals of
time?"
Third question. "Why did you not perform all your works in a single hour?"
Fourth question. "Why did your body grow over intervals of time and not in
an instant?"
Fifth question. "As your death was approaching, why did you not reveal
yourself in your divine power, and why did you not show your severity to your
enemies, when you said: 'All is accomplished'?"
Answer to the first question. The Judge answered: "O friend, I respond to you
and yet not to you. I respond to you in order that the evil of your thoughts may be
made known to others. Yet I do not respond to you, because these things are not
revealed for your benefit but for the profit and warning of present and future
generations. Since you do not intend to change your obstinate attitude, you will not
pass from your death into my life, because, while still alive, you hate true life.
Others, however, who have heard about your life, or rather your death, will pass
over and fly on to my life. Indeed, it is written that, for saints, all things work
together unto the good; and God permits nothing to happen without cause. So I
answer you, but not as those do who speak in a human manner, because we are
discussing spiritual things, but in such a way that your thoughts and feelings may
be communicated to others by way of similes.
You ask, then, why I did not show my divine nature openly as I did with my
human. The reason is that my divine nature is spiritual but my human nature is
bodily. Yet the divine and human natures are and were inseparable ever since they
were first joined together. My divinity is uncreated, and all things that exist are
made in it and through it, and every perfection and beauty is found in it. If such
beauty and perfection were visibly revealed to eyes of clay, who would be able to
bear the sight? Who could look upon the physical sun in all its brightness? Who
would not be terrified by the sight of lightning and the sound of thunder? How
much greater the terror would be if the Lord of lightning and the Creator of all
things were seen in his splendor!
My divinity was not openly revealed for two reasons. The first reason is the
weakness of the human body, whose substance is earthly. If any human body were
to see the divinity, it would melt like wax before fire, and the soul would rejoice
with such exultation that the body would be reduced, as it were, to ashes. The
second reason is the immutability of divine goodness. If I were to show bodily eyes
my divinity, which is incomparably more radiant than fire and sun, I would then be
contradicting myself. For I have said: 'No one shall see me and live.' Not even the
prophets themselves saw me as I am in my divine nature. Those who did hear the
voice of my divinity and saw the burning mountain were terrified and said: 'Let
Moses speak to us, and we shall listen to him.' This is why I, merciful God, in order
to be understandable to humankind, revealed myself to them in a human form
similar to theirs, which they could see and touch and in which the divine nature is
concealed, so that people might not be terrified by a form unlike their own. Insofar
as I am God, I am not bodily and cannot be portrayed in a bodily manner, but
people can endure to see and hear me in my human nature."
Answer to the second question. "As to why I did not utter all my words in a
single hour, I answer you: Just as it is materially impossible for the body to take in
as much food in one hour as it could manage in a large number of years, so too it
goes against the divine disposition for my words, which are the food of the soul, to
be spoken all in a single hour. As the food of the body is taken in a small amount at
a time so that it can be chewed and then ingested, so too my words had to be
uttered not in one hour but over intervals of time in proportion to the understanding
of those who were to profit from them, so that the hungry might have something to
fill them and then be stirred to higher things."
Answer to the third question. "As to why I did not perform all my works in an
instant, I answer: Some of those who saw me in the flesh came to belief in me,
others did not. It was accordingly necessary for those who did believe to be taught
by words over intervals of time and to be stirred at times by example and
strengthened by works. For those who did not believe, however, it was right and
just that their wicked disposition be disclosed and tolerated, as far as my divine
justice could permit it. If I had performed all my works in an instant, everyone
would have followed me from fear rather than from love, and, in that case, how
would the mystery of human redemption have been fulfilled?
Just as in the beginnings of the world's creation all things were accomplished
at different times and in different ways - although all the things to be made were
immutably present together in my divine foreknowledge - so too in my human
nature everything was accomplished rationally and distinctly for the salvation and
edification of all."
Answer to the fourth question. "As to why my body grew over a number of
years and not instantaneously, I answer: The Holy Spirit, who is eternally in the
Father and in me, the Son, revealed to the prophets what I would do and suffer
when I came in the flesh. Accordingly, it pleased God that I should take such a
body in which I could labor from morning to evening and from year to year until
the last moment of death. Therefore, in order not to make the words of the prophets
seem meaningless, I, the Son of God, took a body like Adam's but without sin so
that I would be like those whom I was to redeem. In this way, man, who had turned
away from me, might by means of love be led back and, having died, might be
raised up, and having been sold might be redeemed."
Answer to the fifth question. "As to why I did not reveal my divine power and
my true divine nature to everyone, when I said on the cross: 'It is accomplished,' I
answer: It was necessary that everything that had been written about me should be
fulfilled. Accordingly, I fulfilled them all down to the last detail. Since many things
had also been predicted about my resurrection and ascension, it was necessary that
they, too, should be brought about.
If my divine power had been revealed at my death, who would have dared to
take me down from the cross and bury me? And it would have been a small thing
for me then to come down from the cross and lay low my crucifiers - but how then
would the prophecy have been fulfilled or where then would my virtue of patience
have been? And if I had come down from the cross, would everyone have believed
then? Would they not have said that I had done it all by evil art?
Given that they had been indignant when I raised the dead and cured the sick,
they would have said much more had I come down from the cross! Therefore, in
order to set the captive free, I, who was free, made myself captive; and in order to
save the guilty, I, who was guiltless, stood steadfast on the cross. By my
steadfastness I steadied the unsteady and strengthened the strengthless."